Booths vs. No Booths
By Jerrod "Thousand Eyes" Steis
Recently the big stink going around the
LCS circuit is over the implementation, or lack thereof, of soundproof booths.
Anyone who watches LCS today will see the players are in an open air
environment and are fully visible to fans. This was to promote intimacy between
fans and players, just like almost any other sport. However, LoL, and E-sports in
general, aren't like other sports. There’s a lot of deception and trickery as
well as other things that need to be hidden from the opposing team. Most sports
remedy this by having a playbook or sidelines where these plans are relayed out
to the field. Imagine, in football, if the audience told the other team what
play they were running. That’s the best analogy for what the LCS is dealing
with at the moment.
Riot’s always run a thin line between having the
audience feel engaged with the game, and the audience actually being part
of the game. The LCS is run in an open atmosphere
where players and spectators see things at almost the same time. Riot has
admitted there is a slight delay, but even still, players know the delay.
Players wear sound-proof headsets and small earbuds that go underneath. These
headsets don’t completely block out all sound, but they at least do something
to keep players from hearing anything from the audience that might change the
outcome of the game. However, even if they can’t make out specific words,
cheers alone can be enough to understand what's occurred. Let’s look at what
the crowd generally cheers for in the LCS:
·
Wards
·
Towers
·
Dragons
·
Barons
·
Kills
·
Steals
of any kind
Of all of these, the only ones that
aren’t always visible to both teams are Dragons and Barons. Based on positioning
of the enemy it can be pretty simple to make out what was done and have
an almost exact timer for it if the audience is heard. Krepo has even come out
himself to say that players are well aware of both the crowd and the delay that
they’re seeing.
This set up has recently come under fire
as Complexity’s ADC ROBERTxLEE stated on his stream that there was a point in
his match against Curse where he wasn't sure what was being said on the comms.
This wasn't an issue with headsets not working properly either. The sound that
was being heard was coming through his teammates mics. Riot absolutely needs to
address this issue. Communication between teammates in a game as cooperative as
LoL is paramount. Most of the time, plays happen in League because the other
team didn't work as a cohesive unit for one reason or another. If this persists
and happens again, it could easily swing the outcome of a game, and
consequently a season, if it occurs at the right (or in this case wrong) time.
Ideas have been passed around for a while
now, and the most readily accepted one is the implementation of booths. Booths
have been used in many E-sports games. Starcraft and Dota usually use booths
for their events for the exact reason that people are clamoring for them now. They
do a better job at keeping sound out of players hearing range than headsets
alone. In fact, OGN, the Korean LoL league, uses both of them
The only issue here is the possibility of
these booths being little to no use in terms of effectiveness. People have
argued that considering the strength of the headsets used, the diminishing
returns of adding a booth are almost non-existent. The headsets used in the LCS
are approved for use near jet engines, meaning that if sound gets through them,
theoretically, a booth isn’t going to do much to stop it. The other issue comes
with vibrations.
Obviously sound comes from vibrations,
and at events like the LCS there’s not only a lot of sound, but a lot of other
things that can cause vibrations as well. (e.g. feet stomping, inflatable noise
makers, etc.) Booths and headsets do nothing to stop this and it can cause all
of the issues that come with sounds. For large scale crowds, there really is no
effective way to keep things from being heard outside of playing from a remote
area, and Riot will do anything to keep that from happening.
The normal LCS crowd has a few hundred
people. According to most, albeit self-proclaimed, sound experts, vibrations shouldn't be an issue routinely faced in the LCS. World’s may be another issue,
but normal games leading up to the world playoffs should see at least some
effectiveness from booths.
There’s also been the argument of money.
To be honest, it’s hard to get a grasp on which side of the argument is really
true here. It’s more an issue of conflicting information rather than one side
being right or wrong. I’ve seen reports of the LCS making Riot tons of money,
and I’ve seen other information that says the LCS actually loses money in
exchange for further advertising the game. There’s no official information
straight from Riot so I can’t actually confirm which side is correct. This is
in addition to varying booth prices. Depending on how high tech Riot would get
if they decided on booths, the prices could go from a few hundred each or into
the thousands. If it’s true that the LCS doesn't make money, it’s easy to see
how Riot could refrain from putting more money into booths.
Personally, I find myself siding with
putting booths on stage. Riot has always prided themselves on keeping
player/audience interaction high, but at this point there are enough other ways
for players to interact that the negatives outweigh the positives. Even if they
decide against booths, there needs to be some kind of statement as to why or
what Riot intends to do. There’s no reason to not comment on this considering
the amount of backlash that has occurred. Fans need to at least hear a reason
and keeping quiet about this will only increase the controversy as people make
up their own reasons.
